6 Trendy Cookies You Need to Try!

A recent survey of cookie preferences found that 62% of Americans prefer chocolate chip cookies above any other cookie. And really, who could blame them? That tantalizing aroma with ooey-gooey melted chocolate chips for a classic taste that those young and young at heart adore.

But these days, cookies aren’t simply limited to just the standard ingredients and recipes your grandmother used to make. There are so many ways to customize and adapt recipes however you like for the most creative cookies imaginable. 59% of people polled said that they would be open to trying new flavor profiles and creative cookie recipes.

If your palette demands more variety than the regular chocolate chip cookie can offer, you’re in luck. In this post, we’ll delve into trendy cookies and new cookie ideas that are sure to have your mouth watering. Keep reading below for more details on 6 trendy cookies you should try. 

1. Lucky Charms Marshmallow Cookies

A throwback to your childhood, now you can have the taste of one of your beloved cereals in a handheld cookie format. For an extra boost of nostalgia, incorporated crushed-up non-marshmallow cereal pieces into the dough to enhance the classic Lucky Charms cereal taste.  

You need 1-1½ cups of whole Luck Charms marshmallows, 1 large egg, ½ teaspoon of vanilla extract, ½ cup of brown sugar tightly packed, ½ teaspoon of salt, ½ teaspoon of baking soda, ¾ of a teaspoon of baking powder, ¼ of unsalted butter, and 1 cup of unbleached all-purpose flour. 

Cream the butter and brown sugar together, then add in the egg and the vanilla extract. Mix the dry ingredients in a separate bowl. Slowly incorporate the dry mixture into the brown sugar and butter until it is well blended and contains no lumps.

Stir in the white chocolate chips and marshmallow pieces into the batter for even more added flavor. Bake for about 10 minutes at 350° or until they are lightly golden brown.

Sprinkle the cookies with colored sugar sprinkles and place your favorite marshmallow pieces on top. Not only are these creative cookies fun to look at, but they’re also the perfect snack for dunking into a cold glass of milk. 

2. Birthday Cake Cookies

One of the best things about celebrating a birthday, whether it’s yours or someone else’s, is the cake. But what if you didn’t have to wait for a special occasion to enjoy some tasty birthday cake flavors? Even better, what if it was portable enough to take with you wherever you went?

Birthday cake cookies are the best of both worlds, these creative cookies combine the tasty flavor of a slice of birthday cake into the compact and snackable form of a cookie. It’s a buttery sugar cookie with a layer of cake batter-flavored frosting. And it’s topped with bright and colorful rainbow sprinkles. 

According to The Mad Hatter from Alice in Wonderland, you have 364 Un-Birthdays to celebrate. With this cookie, you really can have your cake and eat it too. 

3. Cinnamon Macchiato Cookies

Looking for the perfect accompaniment to your morning coffee or as an afternoon pick-me-up snack? Cinnamon Macchiato Cookies are wonderfully creative cookies that amp up your regular cookie’s flavor profile a notch. 

Using powdered espresso mix with the standard cookie dough recipe enhances the flavor and gives you a much-needed boost. With espresso chips, white chocolate chips, and cinnamon also in the mix, you’ll have a melt-in-your-mouth sensation that beats a regular old donut any day of the week. 

You’ll want to reach for a cold glass of milk or dunk them into your coffee for even more deliciousness. If you bring a box of these into your workplace, your co-workers are certain to thank you. 730 855 980

4. Dark Chocolate Coconut Cookies

While 49% of Americans favor milk chocolate the most, about one-third or 34%, prefer dark chocolate. Dark chocolate is not as sweet or as creamy, but when it comes to creative cookies, it has its own merits.

Before you shake your head and think, “That’s not my style”, let’s explore a little bit. A Dark Chocolate Coconut Cookie is a unique blend of flavors. The dark chocolate cookie base will not be as overpoweringly sweet as others may be. 

A layer of sweet coconut-flavored buttercream offers a great interplay that counters the bitterness of the dark chocolate. It provides just the right amount of sweetness to compliment and balance the flavor profile. It’s sprinkled with some toasted coconut on top for extra texture.

5. Chocolate Chip Potato Chip Cookies

Some people like sweet and salty in their snack foods. Potato chips seem to compliment everything, even your standard chocolate chip cookies. That’s why they may just be the next best thing to add to your recipes for creative cookies.

Potato chips come in pretty much every flavor imaginable, so it seemed inevitable that chocolate-covered potato chips would become a new trend. Now you can even use them in trendy cookies. If you can’t decide whether your snack choices lean toward more salty or more sweet options, now you can have both. 

Putting potato chips into chocolate chip cookies not only satisfies these two cravings at once, but it also provides a satisfying potato chip crunch when you bite into them.

6. S’Mores Cookies

If you love the taste of marshmallows but prefer regular marshmallows over the Lucky Charms variety, you can still have all of the chocolatey goodness you love with a chocolate chip cookie and the rich gooeyness of a marshmallow together. Make your very own s’more-style creative cookies.

Adding crushed-up graham crackers to the cookie batter makes your cookies into a handheld s’more with full flavor and less mess. Use extra cinnamon and sugar for more sweetness.

You can place a fun-size Hershey bar inside of the cookie dough balls before baking or push it into the top before you put it into the oven. Add your marshmallows on top and watch them turn golden brown and gooey as the cookies bake or toast them with a kitchen torch after the cookie base bakes.

S’mores cookies are trendy cookie ideas that everyone will love.

Find More Delicious and Creative Cookies at Batch Cookie Shop 

One of the best things about cookie recipes is that you can always adapt and change your recipes however you want. There’s no limit to what you can come up with for creative cookie recipes.  

Batch Cookie Shop, located in Gilbert, AZ, is a family-owned small business that wants to share the sweetness of family recipes and trendy cookie ideas to make the tastiest and most creative cookies possible for our customers.

Check out our website for new cookie ideas each week. Have our cookies delivered by DoorDash or stop by our shop. 

Place an order on our website today.